Is 'Torontoness' the Answer to the Canadian Identity Crisis?
Over the weekend, Tom Kent's widely-read piece on Canadian citizenship, "Canada is much more than a hotel," appeared in the Globe and Mail. Kent, a former assistant to Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson, argues that Canada's citizenship and immigration laws require updating. Kent raises some important points which deserve an honest vetting, but - typical of the genre - his conclusions are ultimately confusing. One can't demand loyalty, but can "encourage it" through taxation and obligatory citizenship. Loyalty, in turn, serves to strengthen our flagging sense of identity, a weakness that is "our special Canadian problem." Only when we believe ourselves to be Canadian - and only Canadian - can we make a difference in a complex and interdependent world. Less interconnectedness apparently goes further in an interconnected world.
Several weeks ago, I attended a Maclean's debate featuring New Yorker writers Adam Gopnik and Malcolm Gladwell on - wait for it - Canadian identity. As we settled into our seats, a sense of giddy apprehension pervaded U of T's Convocation Hall. One has to wonder if a society that readily commits to congregating to discuss identity problems (even paying for the pleasure) doesn't share the same masochistic loyalty of couples chronically in therapy. Perhaps Mr. Kent need not worry.
Thanks to Maclean's attempt to engender a livelier debate by recruiting "new voices" - those of Canadian writers who haven't lived here for the past ten years or more - not much was added to the cannon familiar to debating clubs across Canada. With such threadbare material, the debate was ultimately one of style. While Gladwell offered buzz-word theories to admirably distill complex ideas into uncomplicated Kool-Aid, Gopnik relied on his gifts of close observation (read people-watching) and lyrical oration. Ultimately, Gopnik held us in rhythmic sway, describing his recent ascent of Montreal, where he saw not a city, but a kaleidoscope of contributions made by individuals with strongly-hued identities of their own - shards of brightly-coloured glass that together mesmerize and inspire us.
It was only later when I tuned into the weekly broadcast of Laurie Taylor, BBC's sociologist of the people, that I realized that I had failed to observe something key about the debate. Gopnik's crowning moment - to which the audience responded with the loudest applause of the night - wasn't about a country, it was about a city.
Continue reading "Is 'Torontoness' the Answer to the Canadian Identity Crisis?" »










